|
Aşağıdaki yazı ve kullanılan resimler 'The Wave Mag' adlı derginin websayfasından alınmış olup,
yazının orijinali http://www.thewavemag.com/pagegen.php?pagename=article&articleid=22477 adresindedir.
Seanbaby takma adını kullanan yazar, Türk sineması ve Türkiye ile ilgili olarak, alaycı olmaktan da öte sert ve hakaretamiz ifadeler kullanmaktadır.
Yazarımız Alper Eğmir'in eşref saatine denk gelirse bu makaleyi Türkçe'ye çevireceğine inanıyoruz.
(Siz sayın okurlarımızdan biri zahmet eder de çevirirse, ayrıca bahtiyar olacağız.)
O zamana kadar, İngilizce bilen okurlarımız için yazının orijinal metnini aşağıda sunuyoruz.
|
Video Review: The Turkish Exorcist
When Turkey Remakes Classic American Films, our Intrepid International Film Critic is on the Report
By Seanbaby
In the year 2000, The Exorcistwas
modified and re-released in theaters. It was hailed as a brilliant
twist on the tired formula of only showing movies you haven't seen
before. But before the American film industry gives itself a trophy, it
should know that Turkey was years ahead of us when they made their own
improved version of The Exorcist in 1974. Only, they called it Seytan.
It starts much like our version, with Father Merrin investigating an
archeological dig in the desert. He finds a brass devil face on the
ground being torn up by clumsy workers with pick axes who continue to
dig while he examines it. There's no dialogue yet, but the father's
grumpiness seems to imply that he'd rather the diggers stop wildly
swinging their pick axes next time they come across a priceless
artifact. Curators have to be constantly telling him, "Father, while we
here at the museum thank you for your work, we do not have the space to
display any more piles of ancient something chunks your men find, then
destroy."
I've reviewed the Turkish remakes of Star Trek, Wizard of Oz,
Star Wars, Superman and ET,
which were set in a cave, a cave, a cave, a cave, and an animal carcass
filled street, respectively. It's nice to see that this film takes
place in the lovely furnished home of a rich mother and daughter.
However, unlike the others, it doesn't have any naked Tarzan robots,
pervert midgets, trampoline cookie monster fights, a Superman toy on
strings and a smoke farting alien puppet, respectively, so the film has
to get by on the brilliance of its dialogue. That means most of the
film is a total mystery to me and my non-Turkish speaking posse. So I
can really only review its technical aspects.
Cinematography: Half a star
No expense was spared when creating this bad copy of a
movie that. The filmmakers were able to procure cameras that, get this,
zoom.
Zooms can be used as powerful cinematic tools. For example, they can
force a viewer to focus on a character while maintaining the world in
which you've placed them. In this film, the cinematographers were so
excited to finally have a camera that zoomed, they lost all narrative
and artistic meaning. There is not one person or object that enters
this movie without first speeding at or away from the camera.
The best showcasing of the overused zoom shot comes in a scene
that begins with a tight shot of a bowl of baked beans. The viewer may
ask, "Why are we among these beans? What could this bowl of baked beans
mean?" Then, it dramatically zooms out to reveal… My God! Someone's
eating these beans for dinner! Also, I should tell you that one of the
cameras used to film this movie tints everything purple. It's possible
this is some sort of artistic, although insane, use of gel filters.
However, the fact that this pink camera doesn't ever zoom supports my
main theory that it's just kind of broken.
Acting: Three stars
It's
quite possible that these are fine actors. The Turkish language sounds
a lot to me like Dracula squeezing a mouthful of pudding through his
teeth while he scolds someone from inside a washing machine, and it's
difficult for me to tell if they're doing that right or wrong. The
young priest has a very strong presence, which might be because I think
he looks like a Turkish Greg Brady, and will be referred to as such
from here on. I will continue to refer to the exorcist by his American
character's name, Father Merrin, because if I'm hearing it correctly,
his name in this movie is Mrfnblorsh Ayjinorp.
Music: Half a star
The eerie piano music in the film is recorded directly from a record
player playing the original Exorcist
theme from three apartments away. But even this wavering, scratchy
version can create a tense fear. Or at least it could have if they
hadn't restarted the song every time the camera cut to something. At
one point they're playing it while the mother is having a funny
conversation with Greg Brady during a tennis game. And sure it made
their lighthearted game a little spookier, but I've always felt that a
chatty game of tennis should have a different soundtrack than two
priests fighting a soup-spitting flying demon girl.
Editing: One star
We're
spoiled in this country with our "transitions." Turkish audiences don't
seem to mind if say, for example, a scene of Greg Brady carrying his
dead mother's coffin to her grave gets interrupted by a scene of a man
hitting on a preteen girl at a birthday party. Incidentally, for
fashion reasons, I decided this man was probably named Mariachi Ted.
Special Effects: One star
The Exorcist showed audiences that once Satan gets hold of a
little girl's soul, all kinds of things happen. She pees on herself,
her bed starts shaking, and her rotating head launches food. All of
these scenes also made it into the Turkish version.
When
the girl pees on herself, right in the middle of Mariachi Ted's
impromptu piano recital by the way, the Turkish effects team create the
illusion of pee by having a thick gray syrup slop from inside her
nightgown and onto her feet in huge globular plops. I've never seen a
Turkish person pee, but given their diet of rocks and unicorn meat,
it's entirely possible that it looks like this.
To make a bed look like it's moving under its own power is
hard. You'd need like hydraulics or... ropes or something. The Turkish
effects team worked around their lack of these things by instead just
having the little girl bounce up and down on the bed and act like she
wasn't trying to do it. It was sort of working, too, until the mom
jumped on with her and the two of them screwed up each other's timing
and just sort of looked like two quadriplegics trying to kill each
other.

The
American version of the girl's vomiting head spinning around became one
of the most recognizable effects in film history. Recreating it was a
challenge the Turkish effects team welcomed, then hilariously failed.
In their version, the girl stands behind a mannequin wearing a
different nightgown from her and slowly turns around. Maybe Turkish
audiences are able to suspend their disbelief hard enough to... yeah,
actually it probably looks like an ugly girl turning around behind a
scarecrow to them, too.
Technical Research: Four stars

Once
it's clear that evil spirits have taken over this levitating,
spackle-puking girl, doctors do everything they can to diagnose and
cure her. The movie features authentic medical techniques when they
x-ray her skull, fumble a spurting IV into her neck and finally end up
putting her face into a paint shaker and letting it vibrate her head
for a few minutes. This doesn't seem to be a special effect. This child
actor really did get jammed into a paint shaker. I don't know enough
about Turkish medical science to know what good that's supposed to do;
maybe the doctors figured, "If Satan's in there, this'll give him
something to think about!"
Comedy: Three and a half stars
After
the doctors rattle her skull at incredible speeds and it fails to remove the satan from it, the girl's mother calls in a hypnotist. The
girl pretends to follow his watch, then with comic timing beyond that
of normal non-demons, she punches him square in the balls. He crunches
into a standing fetal position that is so well-acted that it'd be
impossible to duplicate without actually ramming something dangerous
into your groin. The only reason this film didn't get the full four
stars for Comedy is due to the lack of him waddling out of the room and
saying something retarded in a high-pitched voice.
Linguistics: Four stars
Once
her satanic possession is in full swing, strange words appear on the
girl's stomach. They read, "BANA YARDIM EDIN." Both priests seemed
shocked by this, so I ran it through a Turkish to English translator.
It means "Me Help Provision." Since this totally didn't seem like
something Satan would write on someone's tummy, I ran it through a
Turkish to Japanese and then to English translator. It gave me a choice
from the three following translations:
1. "maker coffee help equipment."
2. "kickboxing branding iron service provision."
3. "mulatto otter aid robot."
I chose number three and shuddered at what the theological implications
of it could have been.
Ending: Negative five stars
Greg
Brady finds the girl over the dead body of Father Merrin and loses it.
He wails on her face, and I mean WAILS on her face. It would take a
team of math scientists just to count the number of times he punches
her in the damn head. Eventually he beats Satan out of her body and
into his, then jumps out a window to his death. The girl is actually
not there for most of this fight, so most of it is just Greg Brady
throwing punches at the camera. This could be because it's so hard to
choreograph a fight scene with a child, but most likely because labor
laws require all Turkish child actors to spend at least six hours a day
away from the set and laboring in the haunted salt mines.

The
film then cuts to a scene of the little girl and her mother, Satan-free
and moving out of their home, currently pasted in several layers of
devil spackle puke. They walk to the church, where the girl runs to a
kindly old man we've never seen before, who rubs her head far longer
than appropriate. Then he continues rubbing, without either of them
saying a word, until it starts to burn a hole in her scarf hat.
Finally, the head rub marathon ends when the girl runs happily away. The
Exorcist
piano theme comes on, then abruptly stops three seconds later to a black screen. In fact, this film ends so abruptly and awkwardly that the only way to end a review of it is by